At the Desk with Dougie and Eleanor, in conversation.

PracticeGuard · At the Desk

The payroll is tidy; the payments are not

Use the file and report · 2 min · With Dougie and Eleanor

Listen to this episode

Download audio · Download transcript · Podcast feed

All 22 episodes — choose another
  1. We only do the accounts · 2 min
  2. Whose client is this? · 2 min
  3. The other twenty-six branches · 2 min
  4. Start now, check later? · 2 min
  5. The company owns another company · 2 min
  6. The green tick did not take the engagement · 2 min
  7. The balance is not the explanation · 2 min
  8. Accounts, with wheels · 2 min
  9. A PEP is not a criminal conviction · 2 min
  10. Same name, different person · 2 min
  11. That is not what the business does · 2 min
  12. Tell the MLRO what happened · 2 min
  13. The good biscuit tin · 2 min
  14. Keep the file, protect the people · 2 min
  15. How we do it here · 2 min
  16. A tax mistake and a deliberate omission · 2 min
  17. The payroll is tidy; the payments are not · 2 min
  18. The attachment is the office · 2 min
  19. When the report must leave the practice · 3 min
  20. A control with nobody doing it · 2 min
  21. The register is one part of the picture · 2 min
  22. A new instruction, a different job · 2 min

Transcript

ELEANOR: Why have you put the payroll file beside the payment instructions?

DOUGIE: Because separately they're very tidy. Together they're having an argument.

ELEANOR: At last, a spreadsheet with interpersonal skills.

DOUGIE: The payroll lists one arrangement. The client wants a change of payee that doesn't fit it. Could be a legitimate change. We need the explanation and authority, not a guess.

ELEANOR: Bookkeepers and payroll staff may see details that nobody onboarding the customer saw. A concern doesn't become irrelevant because you didn't take the original instruction.

DOUGIE: Ask a proportionate professional question. Who is being paid, why did the instruction change and what supports it? Use a trusted contact route where the change itself needs verification.

ELEANOR: Don't assume a shared address or an unusual working arrangement proves wrongdoing. Don't assume a neat payroll report proves the payments are consistent either.

DOUGIE: If something remains suspicious, make the internal report promptly with the facts and documents. Don't run a private investigation into employees or circulate sensitive payroll details unnecessarily.

ELEANOR: The firm also needs the correct service scope. Preparing or analysing payroll information can be regulated work; simply licensing software is a different model. Refer uncertain cases rather than relying on the word 'payroll'.

DOUGIE: Our job is to use what the work shows us. Not to declare 'onboarding passed' and stop noticing for the next three years.

ELEANOR: Then record the decision, any updated risk assessment and the authorised next action. Keep the reporting material in its protected place.

DOUGIE: A useful handover says what changed and what needs deciding.

ELEANOR: Better than forwarding the entire workbook with 'thoughts?' in the subject line.

Sources

Source snapshot for this release, published 14/11/2026.

← Back to all episodes