
PracticeGuard · At the Desk
A tax mistake and a deliberate omission
Use the file and report · 2 min · With Dougie and Eleanor
Listen to this episode
All 22 episodes — choose another
- We only do the accounts
- Whose client is this?
- The other twenty-six branches
- Start now, check later?
- The company owns another company
- The green tick did not take the engagement
- The balance is not the explanation
- Accounts, with wheels
- A PEP is not a criminal conviction
- Same name, different person
- That is not what the business does
- Tell the MLRO what happened
- The good biscuit tin
- Keep the file, protect the people
- How we do it here
- A tax mistake and a deliberate omission
- The payroll is tidy; the payments are not
- The attachment is the office
- When the report must leave the practice
- A control with nobody doing it
- The register is one part of the picture
- A new instruction, a different job
Transcript
DOUGIE: There's income missing from the records. I've asked the client to explain it. ELEANOR: And? DOUGIE: First it was an oversight. Then it was 'best not to complicate things'. The things appear to be the accounts. ELEANOR: Their principal source of complication. DOUGIE: Mistakes happen. We need to distinguish an error being put right from information suggesting deliberate evasion. We don't diagnose intent from one badly phrased email. ELEANOR: Establish the relevant facts through normal professional enquiries. Follow the applicable tax and professional procedures. Then assess whether the information gives rise to knowledge, suspicion or reasonable grounds under the reporting rules. DOUGIE: If concern exists, tell the nominated officer promptly. Don't wait for the client to agree with our interpretation, or negotiate away the reporting question. ELEANOR: Correcting a return doesn't automatically answer whether a report is required. Equally, not every difference of tax treatment means criminal property exists. DOUGIE: Keep the facts separate. What records show, what the client said, what advice was given, and what remains unresolved. Avoid turning the file into a running commentary on the client. ELEANOR: Reporting exemptions and privileged circumstances are specialist questions with conditions. Being an accountant doesn't make every conversation privileged. Refer the actual circumstances through the proper review route. DOUGIE: And don't tell the client a suspicious-activity report has been made as a way to win the argument. Agree safe communication where reporting is involved. ELEANOR: We can be firm, professional and fair without either accusing someone prematurely or ignoring what they've told us. DOUGIE: I've written the client's exact words and attached the relevant entries. My opinion of their filing system stays out. ELEANOR: Good. We haven't got the storage capacity.